Tungsten Vs Titanium – Difference Between Tungsten And Titanium

I know the confusion that comes when you think about jewelry with the presence of many metals today and new ones.

Tungsten and titanium aren’t new to the jewelry world since people have used them to make wedding bands and many other jewels.

These two metals are more popular with male jewelry because of their hardness.

Unfortunately, surface appearance always makes people think that these metals are the same when they are not. Keep reading as we unveil the differences for you to understand it even better.

I know how important this article is going to be for you, especially if you are looking for a choice for your special day.

Today more people are buying the jewels made using these two metals. We all want to be part of the hype but not without knowing the exact differences.

So let’s understand them separately.

Related articles:

Titanium Vs Silver
Titanium Vs Surgical Steel 
Titanium Versus Platinum
Titanium Vs Gold Vs White Gold

Tungsten

Tungsten ring

We all appreciate this steel-colored grey metal. It stands out more to the men because of its robustness and similar density to gold. This metal is also referred to as tungsten carbide, and although most people think it’s for men, women also use the tungsten jewels.

Tungsten carbide, which often makes the jewels contains scarce metals called tungsten and carbon atoms. Here you will have the metals combined in equal ratios.

More reading: Tungsten Vs Tungsten Carbide

Notice, therefore, that the metal that makes its jewelry is never in its pure form, and you would understand that’s because of its rarity.

Besides tungsten metals like silver and gold metals is hard to work with because it’s very brittle. It has the highest melting point, and its brittleness makes it crack easily when you are working with it. Although it’s hard, it remains malleable to craft the different jewels of your choice.

Like the titanium above, its hardness just means that you can’t resize it. Before you go out to buy it, therefore, you should go out and test it.

Notice though that mostly, the tungsten will be mixed with nickel, carbon, and cobalt. This then will make sure you have metal that’s versatile, durable but also easy to work with.

I know we have always said that titanium is the hardest, but when you have tungsten carbide, it’s harder than titanium. People like it most for its scratch resistance as well as forever polished look.

Pros

  • Of all the metals, this one is the most scratch-resistant. If you are afraid of scratching your precious jewel, then maybe you should choose the tungsten carbide.
  • It’s relatively light and notes that it’s also as affordable as the titanium. Yet you will like the appearance.
  • They are more comfortable to wear and remove. If you say had a medical emergency, it would be easier to remove the tungsten than it is to remove the gold jewel.
  • Tungsten is tough, and as such, it will never bend out of shape as the softer materials do.
  • It comes in its grey color, and people like it to maintain the polished look through the time you have it on. You may never need to re-polish it, which means it’s more comfortable to manage than other metals.

Cons

  • The presence of nickel makes it not ideal for those with skin sensitivity.
  • Like titanium, if you bought the tungsten rings, you should choose the perfect fit as you won’t resize it when you need to.
  • It can be hard to tell the difference between the excellent tungsten carbide and other metals that contain cobalt, nickel, and such metals.
  • It’s hard to create different shapes and styles because of its hardness, and the same goes for the titanium jewels as well.

Titanium

Titanium ring 1

We have talked about this in previous blogs already, but it’s an abundant metallic element.

It makes different kinds of jewels today and is favored by both male and female buyers. This is a transitional element in the periodic table.

Its hardness has made it a favorite for many, including those in the jewelry industry and those in aerospace.

It comes in a grey-white color, but you can anodize it to create different other colors of choice. Notice that its hardness makes it ideal for the day to day use without fear of damaging it. If you polish it frequently, then it will serve you over a long time.

Pros

  • Titanium is non-reactive for the most part. This is why you won’t hear of it rusting or tarnishing. It remains as titanium years after you bought it. Notice that you can’t bend them out of shape as it’s a hard metal.
  • You don’t need to maintain it all the time as you do with silver and gold. It will keep its shine, and rarely does it develop the watermarks.
  • It has very minimal thermal conductivity, which means it will maintain the same shape.
  • This metal will last longer due to its hardness. You can’t bend it or damage it quickly; it’s the most preferred for the men.
  • It contains no nickel and such as metals, which is why it’s hypoallergenic. If you are sensitive, you should use the titanium never to cause any reaction to you.
  • Of all metals, there is one of the most affordable options you have.
  • When it’s anodized, you can make different colors, which is why most people like it.
  • These metals maintain the perfect relationship between quality, price, and originality.
  • It’s the ideal answer to male jewelry.

Cons

  • It’s hard to manipulate as you would like to because of the way it’s hard.
  • Titanium has a more matte finish, which makes the rings not shine as much.
  • You can’t resize them even if you wanted to.

What are the differences

The metal composition

Tungsten and titanium have a different composition.

Tungsten is a pure metal that’s made using a compound of two metals. They use the rare tungsten together with carbon atoms.

Now tungsten on its own can’t make the jewels since it a very brittle metal as earlier mention, and no wonder we have the addition of carbon atoms in equal proportions.

Although not often used in its pure form, Titanium can work just as titanium if you wanted to. However, in most cases, you will have it mixed with aluminum or vanadium.

Both metals are safe for the skin. This is why the grade of the titanium jewels matters as they show you the amount of pure titanium in the metal.

The hardness and strength

In this article, both metals are known to be very hard, and that’s why they are also durable. Notice that they are too hard that they are also brittle, and this makes it hard to work with.

In this case, we are comparing both of them to the other precious metals like silver and gold. They will rarely suffer any form of damage.

When you are buying either of these metals, you are buying them to handle tough and rough conditions.

Nonetheless, notice that the hardest one of them all is tungsten its, therefore, more durable. Tungsten will even give you more durable designs. Moreover, it has the forever polish that makes it an even better choice.

The weight

Although the metals are hard, they appear to be the lightest making them even more comfortable. Also, its lightweight quality is excellent if you choose the right jewel just for you.

Titanium is very lightweight but also great looking. If you don’t like to use many different jewels that are going to feel weighty, you will find titanium to be a perfect choice.

Tungsten, even though it’s lighter than most other metals, is dense and makes it weightier than titanium. We have different preferences; some people feel like tungsten is the highest quality, while others feel like titanium. Now all these are just personal preferences.

Scratch resistance

This is a feature that would make any jewel appealing to anybody buying it for the first time. We all want the durable options that we know will last longer.

One factor that affects most of the jewels though is whether they are scratch-resistant or not. You see, even precious metals like gold and silver scratch easily. Of course, the metals here are harder, and therefore, the scratching rarely occurs for them.

In a nutshell, tungsten stands out. It’s better when you know you don’t want the type that will scratch easily. Remember, it’s the hardest metal of all jewelry metals. It’s almost impossible to see the scratches if you even forgot and rubbed it on the surfaces.

It’s ideal for those who aren’t looking to do so much work in the maintenance of their jewels. Nonetheless, both choices are great on this topic as titanium doesn’t scratch easily either.

Hypoallergenic properties

This is a significant factor, primarily for anyone who is skin sensitive because it will determine whether either of the metals is ideal for them. Well, the titanium jewel is the one type you can trust never to cause a skin reaction. Never has anyone complained that the titanium caused their skin reaction.

All the time, this metal is listed in the section of the biocompatible ones. Remember that it’s nontoxic, and it’s also hypoallergenic. This gives you the perfect combo for people with a sensitive type of skin.

Now the tungsten is a little different. In most cases, though, it’s hypoallergenic since it contains the safe metals that make the alloy. If you bought the one that has nickel as part of the alloy, then you can be sure it will serve you.

I know one would say that it has a low level of nickel, but that will still affect anyone who has a nickel allergy.

Notice too, that tungsten also has cobalt, and some people react to cobalt too. It’s all safe if you don’t react to nickel or cobalt.

The cost

Considering all the goodness that comes with the two metals, we would say they are relatively affordable.

If you were to compare it to other metals like gold and platinum, you would understand why we say it is way cheaper.

Notice that of the two, even though it’s harder to mine the titanium, tungsten is a little more expensive. Most people say it’s easier to work with titanium, so it’s cheaper. Also, when you think if it tungsten is rarer, which makes it more expensive.

Does any of them crack?

Of course, you should know this point before you go out to buy any metal of your choice. Both of these metals are hard and durable, so you won’t have issuers to do with cracking.

When you look at it keenly though you will notice something, the tungsten may crack faster. This is because of the composition. If it ever has to bend, then it will start to crack first. Titanium just doesn’t.

Which one looks best?

The two metals will come to you in their silvery color. But I know you want to ask if it will maintain the shine through the time you have it on. Titanium will hold its shine much better of the two. But if you want even more spice, you can anodize the titanium to get it in other colors.

You can do the same for the tungsten though using the plating method. Unfortunately, the plating will often peel off over time. So you will need to re-plate it from time to time.

Do they make jewels in their pure form?

I know purity is what you want to hear, but the truth is that even the gold, silver, and platinum are never in their pure form when making the jewels.

Tungsten is very brittle to make the jewel by itself, and we had mentioned this. Titanium is equally very hard, and this makes it hard to work with that’s why they make alloys.

Which one is better?

I know in the end this is what you wanted me to tell you. But you see it depends on personal preferences. Based on the features above, which one appeals to you more? They both look good, so it will be upon you to order and wear them to know the one that works best for you than another.

Leave a Comment